Aquinas: Dumb Ox or Angelic Doctor?

Staff

Aquinas: Dumb Ox or Angelic Doctor?

How many angels can sit on the head of a pin? Was it harder for God to create the universe than to create man? In the resurrection, will man get back the rib he lost in Eden?

Such questions were debated by the scholastics, the theologians of the Middle Ages.

While today we might laugh at such questions, we also can appreciate a certain aspect of their thinking--they took Truth seriously, and they wanted to know every detail about God and his creation. The greatest of all the Scholastic theologians was Thomas Aquinas.

glimpsesorder back issues of this story

Thomas was born about 1225 into a dynamic age--the age of chivalry, the Crusades, and Marco Polo. Towns were competing with one another to build taller and more glorious Gothic cathedrals. As the younger son of the Count of Aquino, near Naples, Italy, Thomas was also born into a well-connected family, related to the Holy Roman Emperor Frederick and descended from the famous crusader Tancred.
Yet Thomas lived largely apart from the attractions of this medieval world, focusing instead on affairs of the mind. When he was five, his parents sent him to the prestigious monastic school at Monte Cassino. As his family saw it, Thomas could use his religious education to obtain a lucrative and influential position as an abbot or even archbishop. But this young man had other ideas. While studying at the University of Naples, Italy, Thomas chose to enter the Dominican order, taking a vow of poverty. His parents were outraged when they found out. Being religious was one thing, but being poor, that just wouldn't do. They quickly attempted some damage control.

When his dad got the Pope to offer him the archbishopric of Naples, Thomas wouldn't take it. How about being abbot of the affluent monastery at Monte Cassino? No, Thomas wasn't budging. In fact, he reaffirmed his vows and set out to study with the Dominicans in Paris.

He never got there. His family had him kidnapped along the way, and they imprisoned him in the tower of a castle for seventeen months. Think of it as a kind of cult deprogramming. Thomas' brothers even hired a prostitute to seduce him. When she entered his room, he knew he had better not leave any room for temptation, so he quickly grabbed a firebrand from the hearth and chased her out. Then he branded the sign of the cross in the door.

As the story goes, his mother was moved by Thomas' determination, and she eventually helped him escape out the window.

The Ox Brays
He went on to study in Paris and Cologne, where he became the pupil and friend of Albertus Magnus, a renowned German theologian. Since Thomas was a big, quiet man, he gained the nickname of "Dumb Ox." But, recognizing the genius inside, Albertus quipped, "This is an ox whose braying all Europe will hear."

After completing his formal studies, Thomas spent the rest of his life teaching theology in Paris and various papal centers in Italy. During the high Middle Ages, all education was in the hands of the church. The schoolmen, or teachers at the medieval schools, tried to systematize the teachings of Scripture and church writers. The great minds of the age, Anselm, Peter Lombard, Hugh of St. Victor, and Duns Scotus, all set their hand to bring some logical order to the first millennium of Christian thought. Aquinas became the greatest of these systematizers. His mentor was right: the "braying" of this plodding scholar reached throughout Europe and beyond. Some have described Aquinas' thought as a lake with many streams flowing into it and many drawing from it, but not a water source itself. It might be true that there was little originality in his work, but Aquinas organized medieval thinking better than anyone else did.

With the strong Muslim presence in Spain and North Africa, as well as the Middle East, Aquinas was concerned about the spread of Christianity. In addition, works by the Muslim writer Averroes, Jewish teacher Maimonides, and the classical Greek philosopher Aristotle had recently been translated into Latin and were being read by European scholars. How should Christians deal with these non-Christian teachings? In response, Aquinas wrote a Manual Against the Heathen as a missionary tool to use with both Muslims and Jews. In the first three sections, Thomas used logic and reason to prove the existence of God, his character, the creation of the world, and his providence. Only in the last part did he turn to Scripture to establish the Trinity and explain the Incarnation of Christ.

His Super Summa
Thomas believed philosophy and reason could aid theology, and his proofs for the existence of God are still used in modern apologetics. He was willing to use Aristotle (whom he called "the philosopher") to discover truths in nature and illuminate the Scriptures. He recognized, however, that some Christian doctrines, such as the Trinity and Incarnation, could not be known without God's revelation.

Of course Thomas' masterpiece is Summa Theologica, a work in three books on God, humanity, and the Redeemer. While the Gothic cathedrals were massive structures of stone and stained glass built for God's glory, the Summa was a massive logical structure assembled to help understand the mind of God. Thomas followed a basic method: first asking a question (such as "Is God a body?"); then listing a series of articles with positive answers (Scripture speaks of God's hand or eyes, we are made in God's image); then listing a series of articles with negative answers (God is a Spirit); and finally giving his answer to the question, addressing both the positive and negative articles. With 518 questions and 2,652 articles, the Summa is an amazing compilation of medieval thought on theological issues--but this masterpiece was never completed. One morning while at worship, Thomas had a vision. So overwhelming was this experience of God that he never wrote again. He explained that, compared to what had been revealed to him, all that he had written was "straw." The next year, on March 7, 1274, Thomas died at the Cistercian Abbey of Fossanuova.

In 1323 Thomas was canonized (proclaimed a saint) by Pope John XXII, and in 1567 he was recognized as a "doctor of the church." In fact, he became known as the "Angelic Doctor." In 1879, as the Church faced the skepticism of the nineteenth century, Pope Leo XIII commended Aquinas as the safest guide in Christian thought. Aquinas' reconciliation of faith and reason continued to influence church teaching, even into modern times.

Thomas used his gift of rational argument to serve his church. Non-Catholics can applaud his reasoning on basic doctrines like the Trinity and the Incarnation, while they may still quibble with his stance on other issues. Thomas supported the medieval Catholic doctrines on the sacraments, indulgences, purgatory, and transubstantiation (the teaching that communion bread and wine are transformed into the body and blood of Christ), but papal infallibility and the immaculate conception of Mary weren't yet church dogma. His writings were used extensively at the Council of Trent, which formulated Catholic teachings in opposition to the teachings of the Protestant Reformation. In light of all that, it's no wonder that Martin Luther called Thomas' Summa Theologica "the fountain and original soup of all heresy, error, and Gospel havoc." But modern evangelical Norman Geisler expresses the appreciation of many modern Protestant scholars: "Aquinas . . . has helped me to be a better evangelical, a better servant of Christ, and to better defend the faith" (Christian History, Issue 73).

All told, this "dumb ox" pulled Christianity along an important path. Though wrapped in medieval garb, many of the questions with which Thomas struggled continue to face our own generation. Forget about angels dancing on pins. The crucial questions in Thomas' age and ours are the following: What is the relation of reason and revelation? How does the scientific observation of nature fit with our faith? Since Jesus said he is the Truth, how are all other truths related to Him? Sure, sometimes Thomas' arguments rely more on Aristotelian logic than Scripture, and you might disagree with a number of his conclusions, but Thomas led the way in the integration of Christian faith and rational thought. In our day of secularism and materialism, we need all the Christian thinking we can get.

Aquinas' Proofs for the Existence of God

1. From motion:
Motion presupposes an original mover. Whatever is changed or moved must be changed or moved by something else, but an infinite chain of movers would be impossible. Without a "first mover" there would be no movement.

2. From causation:
In nature there are many cause-effect relationships. Tracing back the cause of each effect must bring one to a First Cause.

3. From contingency:
In nature things are created and destroyed. If all that exists could possibly not exist, then at some point in time past nothing could exist at all. However, somewhere there must be a being whose existence is not only possible but necessary. The conditional demands that which is absolute.

4. From degree:
That which is imperfect implies that which is perfect for a standard.

5. From design:
Even unthinking things tend to follow certain patterns and ends, but this is impossible without intelligent design. Objects and events appear to be controlled by an overruling design, like an arrow shot by an archer. Some intelligence must exist which draws all things to their goal and purpose.

  • Editors' Picks

    Why the Church Must Start Talking about Domestic Violence
    Why the Church Must Start Talking about Domestic Violence
  • Don't Think of Church as Your Own Spiritual Power Bar
    Don't Think of Church as Your Own Spiritual Power Bar
  • So You Think Theology Is Impractical?
    So You Think Theology Is Impractical?