The Case for Christ - Week of August 14

Was the Gospel of John Written by Someone Close to Jesus?

Verse:  John 5:1-15  

Archaeology may support the credibility of Luke, but what do scientists say about John, whose Gospel was sometimes questioned because he referred to locations that couldn’t be verified? Some scholars have charged that if he failed to get these basic details straight, then he must not have been close to the events of Jesus’ life. Some have even speculated that John may have been written well into the second century.

These charges, however, have been turned upside down in recent years. For example, John 5:1–15 records how Jesus healed an invalid by the Pool of Bethesda. John provides the detail that the pool was surrounded by five colonnades. For a long time people cited this as an example of John being inaccurate, because no such place had been found.

However, in a more recent excavation of the Pool of Bethesda—it lies maybe 40 feet below ground—archaeologists discovered five porticoes, that is, five colonnaded porches or walkways, exactly as John had described. And there are other discoveries—the Pool of Siloam from  John 9:7 , Jacob’s Well from  John 4:12 , the probable location of the Stone Pavement near the Jaffa Gate where Jesus appeared before Pilate in  John 19:13 ---all of which have lent historical credibility to John’s Gospel.

These discoveries challenge the allegation that the Gospel of John was written by someone distant from Jesus and who lived long after Jesus’ ministry. In addition to these discoveries, archaeologists have found a fragment of a copy of  John 18  that leading papyrologists have dated between A.D.100 and 150, with the earlier date being preferred. German scholar Adolph Deissman said it should be dated to the 90s. By establishing that copies of the Gospel of John existed this early and as far away as Egypt, archaeology has effectively dismantled speculation that the Gospel was composed well into the second century, too long after Jesus’ life to be reliable.

— Adapted from interviews with Dr. John McRay

This devotion is from the NIV Case for Christ Study Bible by Zondervan. Used with permission.

About The Case for Christ

Learn all about Christianity at with rich, theological articles, video, and audio focused on the life of Jesus Christ, Bible Study, the Christian church, and Christian living for families. Grow in your faith and walk with Christ as you read about the history of Christianity, salvation, evangelism and discipleship. Use free daily devotionals from your favorite pastors, authors, and speakers as a way to spend daily quiet time with God. Discover how devotions can help you make postive changes in your life toward living out the promises of God. also offers free online Bible study tools with over 30 translations and a library of commentaries, concordances, lexicons, and more for you to highlight, take notes in, and bookmark for studying the Word!

Editors' Picks

  • 4 Reasons to Pursue Humility
    4 Reasons to Pursue Humility
  • 5 Popular but False Beliefs about Faith
    5 Popular but False Beliefs about Faith
  • Work Is Not a Curse
    Work Is Not a Curse