Christian Foundations

E-Mail Newsletters

    • Study in My BST
    • Email
    • Print
    • Discuss
    • Bookmark and Share
Product photo

AVERAGE USER RATING

Rate this article

What's Wrong with "User Friendly"?

John MacArthur

Grace to You

Recently, the 11th edition of the Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary was published. The reprint included 10,000 new words– words that will bring us all up to date. Words like "phat" (excellent), "dead presidents" (paper currency), and "McJob" (low paying, dead-end job) are among the entries that will finally help us communicate with our teenagers.

How did those words make it into the updated dictionary? There is one criterion: usage. A word qualifies for the new edition based on how widespread its usage has become. While I can't imagine how phat, McJob, and dead presidents will find a place in America's pulpits (e.g., The love of dead presidents is the root of all kinds of evil?), there is one phrase borrowed from the computer industry that has spread into mainstream usage in the church– it's impact has been monumental.

"User-friendly" was first used to describe software and hardware that is easy for the novice to operate. Applied to the church, it describes churches that offer a decidedly benign and non-challenging ministry model. In practice, it has become an excuse for importing worldly amusements into the church in an attempt to attract non-Christian "seekers" or the "unchurched" by appealing to their fleshly interests. The obvious fallout of this preoccupation with the unbelievers is a corresponding neglect of true believers and their spiritual needs.

If you want to know how user-friendly a church has become, the emphasis, or de-emphasis, on biblical preaching is the yardstick. A church that buys into the new paradigm sidelines provocative and convicting sermons for music, skits, or videos– less confrontational mediums for conveying the message. Even when there is a sermon, it is frequently psychological and motivational rather than biblical. Above all, entertainment value and user-friendliness are paramount.

I once read through a stack of newspaper and magazine articles that highlight a common thread in the user-friendly phenomenon. These observations from newspaper clippings describe the preaching in user-friendly churches:

    • "There is no fire and brimstone here... Just practical, witty messages."
    • "Services at [the church featured in the article] have an informal feeling. You won't hear people threatened with hell or referred to as sinners. The goal is to make them feel welcome, not drive them away."
    • "As with all clergymen [this pastor's] answer is God– but he slips Him in at the end, and even then doesn't get heavy. No ranting, no raving. No fire, no brimstone. He doesn't even use the H-word. Call it Light Gospel. It has the same salvation as the Old Time Religion, but with a third less guilt."
    • "The sermons are relevant, upbeat, and best of all, short. You won't hear a lot of preaching about sin and damnation, and hell fire. Preaching here doesn't sound like preaching. It is sophisticated, urbane, and friendly talk. It breaks all the stereotypes."
    • "[The pastor] is preaching a very upbeat message... It's a salvationist message, but the idea is not so much being saved from the fires of hell. Rather, it's being saved from meaninglessness and aimlessness in this life. It's more of a soft-sell."
So the new rules may be summed like this: Be clever, informal, positive, brief, friendly, and never, never use the H-word.

The pastors and leaders in the church-growth movement certainly wouldn't portray their own ministries in that way. In fact, they would probably laud their success in drawing people into the church without compromising the message. But they fail to understand that by decentralizing the Scripture and avoiding hard truths, they are compromising. "For whoever is ashamed of Me and My words, of him will the Son of Man be ashamed when He comes in His glory, and the glory of the Father and of the holy angels" (Luke 9:26, emphasis added). If the design is to make the seeker comfortable, isn't that rather incompatible with the Bible's own emphasis on sin, judgment, hell, and several other important topics?

1 | 2 | Next
Most Recent User Comments
rlmayhan
3/6/2009 9:11 AM
I'm a former Bible church minister who has just returned to Christ after 25 years prodigal. I'm encouraged to see John still sporting a vibrant message.

Thank you,

Richard
http://prodigaleye.org
http://prodigalweb.net
methuselah1936
2/17/2009 3:29 AM
The reasons Johm McArthur mentions in this article seem to be the reason for me to fall asleep in church... A good sermon should not lul you to a comfortable sleep but keep you on the edge of your seat. Decades ago I attended a re3vival meeting in Germany were an Amercan Guest Speaker/Evangelist by the name of Jim Merryl spoke. He had a wonderful name for the people attending church in comfort. Jim called the Sessel Christen. (Translated as Clubchair Christians.)

People wake up! Don`t waste your time in a church of `Sessel Christen`.

Gunter Kirchhoff
goldenoldie72"gmail.com
emk4507
1/18/2009 10:35 AM
I think John McArthur has written timely message that I wish all readers would heed. The Bible warns of "a different gospel" that would come into the church and preach "another Jesus." That is the state of many churches today. The gospel has been adjusted to suit the hearers--to "tickler their ears." He says what needs to be said very well. My local church has gone this direction. Changes are being made to revamp the whole structure of the church to attract younger people and the "old" path is being replaced with the new modern, more acceptable version of Christianity. There is no conviction of sin. The Bible says when the Holy Spirit comes, He will convict the world of sin, so if the Holy Spirit were in the services there would be conviction and repentance. The Holy Spirit is not involved. It is "another gospel."
Sign up to post your comments

It's quick and easy to register with Christianity.com! Just fill out the short form below. You'll have the oppurtunity to post comments, and be more involved in our community and forums. Plus, with this one account, you can sign in anywhere in our network of sites displaying the Salem All-Pass logo, including Oneplace.com, Christianity.com, Lightsource.com, Crosscards.com, and more!

Subscriber Login
Username
Password
Salem Web Network All-Pass: One account that can be used to log onto any page that displays this logo

Salem All-Pass: With one account, you can sign in on any site that displays the Salem All-Pass logo.